Methodology

This page explains how SelfControlAtlas produces content: the four-layer content system, the de-identification rules, the evidence standards, and the quality checks applied before publication. It is the reference for anyone who wants to understand how much to trust a given page.

Last updated: 2026-10-23 · Last reviewed: 2026-10-23

1. The four-layer content system

Content is organized into four layers, each with a distinct epistemic status. The layers are kept separate so that a research finding is never confused with a community observation, and a single person's story is never presented as a universal fact.

Layer 1 — Experiences

De-identified first-person accounts of recovery. An experience is one person's report, not a fact about everyone. It is structured (trigger, strategy, outcome, timeline) so it can be compared with others, but it is never generalized beyond itself.

Layer 2 — Patterns

Recurring observations aggregated across many experiences. A pattern says "this appears frequently across accounts," not "this is universally true." Patterns are supported by counts or clear recurrence, never by a single anecdote.

Layer 3 — Problems

Common questions (e.g., "What is a flatline?", "Should I track my streak?") answered by synthesizing patterns and evidence. Answers state what is known, what is uncertain, and where to get professional help.

Layer 4 — Evidence

Research summaries tied to published sources and graded by the evidence tiers below. Evidence is kept separate from community data so that a research finding is never confused with a community observation.

2. Why four layers?

The four-layer structure addresses two common errors in this space:

  1. Treating anecdotes as evidence. An experience is one person's report. Without a separate "evidence" layer, it is easy to mistake a vivid story for a proven effect.
  2. Treating findings as guarantees. A research finding is an average or an association, not a promise about any individual. Without a separate "patterns" layer, it is easy to overstate what a study means for a given person.

By keeping the layers separate, the site can be both honest about its sources and useful to readers.

3. De-identification rules

Before any community-derived content is published, editors apply these rules:

The objective is that no reader can identify the person behind an experience, and no personal information about community members is published.

4. Evidence standards and tiers

Research summaries are graded using evidence tiers, from strongest to weakest:

  1. Official classifications — e.g., WHO/ICD-11 definitions of compulsive sexual behavior disorder.
  2. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses — the highest-quality syntheses of primary research.
  3. Primary studies — individual peer-reviewed studies, with their limitations noted.
  4. Expert opinion and case reports — labeled as such and given less weight.
  5. Community consensus — useful for describing shared experience, but never presented as scientific evidence.

Editors state the tier a claim rests on, and say so explicitly when evidence is mixed or absent.

5. Separation of evidence and experience

A core rule: evidence and experience are never merged into a single undifferentiated claim. A research summary cites sources; a pattern cites recurrence across accounts. The site does not dress a community anecdote up as a study, and does not dress a study up as a universal truth.

This separation is the single most important methodological commitment, because it prevents the two most common errors in this space: treating anecdotes as evidence, and treating findings as guarantees.

6. Quality checks before publication

Before a page is published or updated, editors check:

7. How problems are answered

Problem pages follow a consistent structure:

  1. What is being asked — restated plainly.
  2. What the evidence says — with the tier stated.
  3. What the community reports — clearly separated from evidence.
  4. What is uncertain — stated honestly.
  5. When to seek professional help — signposted.

This structure prevents a problem page from becoming disguised medical advice.

8. How the knowledge graph is built

The knowledge graph links entities across the site so readers can trace connections:

Links are directional and labeled, so readers move from "what is this?" to "what does the evidence say?" to "what have others experienced?" without losing track of which is which.

9. Corrections and versioning

The current version of any page is authoritative. When an error is corrected:

10. Sourcing practice

When the site cites research, it prefers primary and secondary sources that readers can locate:

Where a source is behind a paywall or not publicly linkable, the site still names the source so readers can find it. The site does not cite sources it cannot verify, and does not fabricate citations.

11. Honesty about uncertainty

Uncertainty is a normal part of research on problematic pornography use. The site labels it rather than hiding it. Where evidence is mixed, weak, or absent, the page says so in plain terms, rather than presenting a confident-sounding but unsupported conclusion.

12. Limitations

See the Disclaimer for the full statement of limitations.

Last updated: 2026-10-23.